In the Age of AI, the Non‑Sacramental Life Is Not Worth Living

November 17, 2026

Share

René Girard’s mimetic theory posits that desire is not intrinsic to each individual but is mediated through others. Girard believes that people choose mediators, or “models” whom they desire to be, and conform their desires to those of the selected model. The result is that the human person is formed within a network of imitative behavior and desire that is personal, relational, and incarnational. While this can and often does lead to rivalries among human beings, when properly ordered, mimetic desire leads the human person to more fully actualize the imago Dei. This ultimately occurs through the imitation of Jesus Christ, who is God incarnate. But for most people, imitation of Christ is mediated by a model who has already successfully learned to imitate Christ. Hence, St. Paul gives the instruction, “Be imitators of me, as I am of Christ” (1 Cor 11:1). This Christian mimetic chain, as I call it, is essential to human formation as well as the formation of Christian disciples. 

Christianity is not learned by reading the Scriptures but is lived incarnationally. It is a “way of life” that requires an active participation mediated through an encounter with individuals who already embody it. These individuals are the people Girard would call “mediators” or “models” of desire. Girard holds that mimetic desire is rooted in interiority, volition, and relationality. As such, a suitable model of imitation will have the ability to examine an interior life, exercise free will, and form relationships that lead all parties towards their proper telos (“intended destiny”) of union with God. While the saints fit this description, for most people, the Christian mimetic chain is forged in a more proximate space. Family members, teachers, pastors, and friends become the models who form our desires. 

This Christian mimetic chain is threatened in the age of artificial intelligence. AI is rapidly invading the spaces where human formation occurs, such as education, communication, social platforms, and even religious education. While aspects of this technology are promising, AI poses a real risk to human formation as it increasingly governs the distribution of “models” to be imitated, and therefore, the formation of human desire. This has the potential to disrupt the Christian mimetic chain, which requires an encounter with a model who is capable of interiority, volition, and relationship. 

While aspects of this technology are promising, AI poses a real risk to human formation as it increasingly governs the distribution of “models” to be imitated, and therefore, the formation of human desire.

AI faces limitations in all three areas. AI cannot desire, it can merely optimize. It does not willfully choose “the good”; it simply predicts. It does not inhabit a world of meaning and relationship; instead, it processes correlations. In short, AI is simply a simulated model (in the Girardian sense). It is never an authentic mediator of desire.

Yet it cannot be denied that AI is entering into the very spaces where both human and Christian formation occurs. Rather than encountering other human beings, these spaces are being filled with “intelligent” machines. Studies show that AI has increasingly become “a personalized source of guidance, emotional support, and decision-making.” Here, we must begin to inquire about the impact and potential dangers of non-human models on the Christian mimetic chain.

The Christian tradition deepens Girard’s thoughts by providing a clearer vision of human anthropology and our telos. The Christian belief that all people are made in the imago Dei contains a corollary truth best summed up by St. Augustine, who wrote, “You have made us for yourself, O Lord, and our heart is restless until it rests in you” (Confessions 1.1). This is the notion that being made in the imago Dei has a built-in telos: union with God. To fully actualize the imago Dei in such a way that leads to union with God requires more than an imitation of God; it requires an actual participation in the life of Christ.

With this in mind, I contend that AI’s threat to disrupt human and Christian formation highlights the necessity of the sacramental life of the Church. This is because the sacramental life of the Church is the means for human beings to participate in the life of Christ. The sacramental life is never lived in a manner that isolates the individual and Christ from all others. Rather the interiority of the sacramental life requires the believer to engage willfully with Christian community in an embodied way so as to actualize the relationship between the individual believer and Christ. In other words, an individual can only become fully actualized as a human being (a creature made in the imago Dei) by willfully choosing to participate in the life of God. Such participation in the divine life is only possible through the sacraments. Jesus himself affirmed this when he stated, “Unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you have no life in you” (John 6:53).

Liturgy of the Hours 2nd Edition
Order Your Set Today

All human formation, and Christian formation in particular, is ordered towards assisting human beings to become more fully actualized. The fully actualized human being is the one who is fully conformed to the imago Dei in which all human beings are made—namely, Jesus Christ. For all other human beings, to become fully actualized requires not simply imitation of Christ, as Girard contends, but participation in the actual life of Christ. This is something that AI cannot provide, despite all its promises. Participation in this life requires the sacraments, which in turn requires an embodied encounter with an “other” human being who can model the interiority, volition, and relationship required by the sacramental life. This is a task that AI cannot and never will be able to accomplish. At best, AI could help a person learn about the sacramental life and its necessity for human beings to become fully actualized. But it will never provide the means for human beings to become fully actualized. That can only occur through encounter and participation in the sacramental life. Anything else will be at best a simulacrum of a human being fully alive. Thus, Socrates’s famous insight regarding the “unexamined life” might be updated for the digital age: “The non-sacramental life is not worth living.”

*A fuller, scholarly development of this argument is currently under review in an academic theological journal.