Shopping cart Shopping cartLog in / Register | Pressroom
Your shopping cart is empty
Home About Us Study Programs WOF TV WOF Radio Written Word Catholicism Series News Ambassador Store Contact Donate end cap
Written Word > Articles & Commentaries > July 2012 > The City Upon a Hill and an Almost Chosen People
Current rating: 4.5 (2 ratings)

The City Upon a Hill and an Almost Chosen People

By Rev. Robert Barron

Ross Douthat’s Bad Religion: How We Became a Nation of Heretics has certainly been the most talked-about book on religion published in 2012. The New York Times op-ed columnist has discussed his work everywhere: CNN, The 700 Club, Andrew Sullivan’s “Daily Beast” video blog, and even “Real Time with Bill Maher.” His central thesis can be rather simply stated: institutional religion is in disarray and decline in America, yet an overwhelming majority of Americans are religious. And this means, Douthat argues, that they have succumbed, for the most part, to heretical versions of classical Christianity, forms of thought that draw a good deal of inspiration from orthodox Christianity but manage to depart from, even pervert, the substance upon which they are parasitic. 

He names and explores a number of these modern day Christian heresies, including the “prosperity gospel,” which more or less identifies the goal of the spiritual life as material success, as well as the “God-Within” religion, which turns the God of the Bible into a greater Self—something like the Oversoul in Ralph Waldo Emerson’s mysticism. This latter heresy is on vivid display, Douthat argues, in much of Oprah Winfrey’s spiritual teaching, in the feel-good ruminations of Deepak Chopra, and in novels such as Eat, Pray, Love, which extols the God “who is in you as you.” Both of these spiritualities borrow extensively from classical Christianity. Thus Joel Osteen, the most popular advocate of the prosperity Gospel, is the son of an evangelical preacher; and Winfrey, Chopra, and their innumerable disciples cite the New Testament and the teachings of Jesus frequently. This blending of Christianity with decidedly un-Christian ideas makes these contemporary ideologies—like the Gnosticism of the second century or the Manichaeism of the fourth century—Christian heresies. I see what Father is doing with the “Oprah, Chopra…” effect, but technically it should be “Winfrey, Chopra…” She has and uses her last name, unlike a Madonna or a Prince, so it should be used. I just wanted to point that out, but that might be overruled.)

Since I’ve written quite a bit about the two heresies mentioned above, I would like to draw attention to a third corruption of Christianity upon which Douthat rather deftly puts his finger. This is the tendency to identify the Kingdom of God, as described in the Bible, with American ideals and the American cultural system. Douthat draws attention to the extraordinary rally organized and led by the conservative political commentator Glenn Beck, during which Beck seamlessly blended his vision of a dominant America with the spiritual aspirations of the prophets of Israel toward the realization of God’s reign. And he observes the affinity between this Beckian perspective and the triumphant affirmation, made most memorably by President George W. Bush in his second inaugural address, of American democracy as a world-saving, God-inspired ideology. That Bush’s claims were much more than abstract became unmistakably clear when the President sent planes, tanks, and troops in order to impose democracy on an Iraq that was utterly unprepared, politically and culturally, for such an imposition. 

Douthat insists that this identification of the American system with divine purpose is by no means the exclusive preserve of conservatives. In fact, in the course of the twentieth century, liberal statesmen have been some of its most devoted advocates. At the close of the First Word War, Woodrow Wilson shared his vision that an American-style democracy, including the rule of law and respect for the rights of ethnic peoples to self-determination, would usher in a world free of war. That Wilson could not even get his own Congress to agree to his pet idea of a League of Nations, and that Europe, within two decades of the end of the First World War, plunged into a second and even more devastating conflagration were rather clear indications of the utopian character of this dream. Moreover, in the middle of the last century, both John Kennedy and Lyndon Johnson offered new versions of the Wilsonian project: the New Frontier and the Great Society, both attempts to realize the Kingdom through political change. Much of the American politics of the last four decades can be read as a response—by turns angry, nostalgic and skeptical—to that earlier utopianism. 

Douthat concludes, quite correctly, that the Kingdom of God, as the Bible envisions it, ought never to be identified with any political or cultural status quo. That Kingdom represents the accomplishment of God’s grace. Hence, every political or cultural system—even one as relatively benign as the American—falls under judgment. And indeed the best of our political and religious figures have clearly understood this. Many American statesmen—Ronald Reagan most recently—have drawn inspiration from John Winthrop’s 1630 sermon “A Model of Christian Charity,” in which the colonial leader spoke of the society he and his fellows were about to found as “a city upon a hill,” which is to say, a visible place of great interest to the rest of the world. If one reads the whole of Winthrop’s homily, it becomes clear that he is not one-sidedly extolling the virtues of the new colony, but just the contrary. He is warning his people that since their experiment in ordered liberty would be carefully watched, they must be vigilant lest sin get the better of them. President-elect Abraham Lincoln, in a February 1861 address to the New Jersey General Assembly, said, “I shall be most happy indeed if I shall be a humble instrument in the hands of the Almighty, and of this his almost chosen people…” How wonderful that Lincoln, who certainly read American history in light of his belief in Divine Providence, was careful not simply to identify America with the chosen people of Israel, but to imply that an “almost chosen” people would always stand in need of correction.

Posted: 7/23/2012 2:44:55 PM by Word On Fire | with 2 comments

Father Barron,
First, we love your programs and outreach.

With regard to your "City on a Hill" article let me humbly recommend you review footage of recent Glenn Beck event where that part of John Winthrop's sermon describing "City on A Hill" is given a very full and accurate reading.
I'm not a Glenn Beck fanatic by any stretch but am impressed and heartened by his efforts to bring faiths together. To equate Beck with triumphant militarism seems mistaken as I believe he was not a Bush supporter and made many anti-war statements. In fact he appears to be a Libertarian - no friend to hegemony.

I believe your point, broadly, is that we should not let political leaders co-opt Christianity using spiritual mandates for wars, programs, policies. Along those lines let us - in all justice - recall a more recent President who unilaterally "sent planes, tanks, and troops in order to impose democracy on an [Libya/Egypt] that was utterly unprepared.." and justified those actions with high sounding moral imperatives.

best wishes!
8/1/2012 3:51:58 PM
Report abuse

Bernard Campbell
I just finished reading "Bad Religion." It is a great book. The material of the book is profound. Like the author, Douthat, over the years, I have tried to understand the "Upheaval" of the past fifty years. This "Upheaval" became widespread and surfaced during the sixties. During these past fifty years, many have written about and debated the source and reason for the global "Social/Religious/Political Upheaval," of this past half century. Douthat did not mention in his book the impact of the two World Wars upon the global community. For it seems to me that these events brought to an end the "divine right of institutions", e.g., Governments. Churches, Academia, Business, Military, even families. It has been my belief that if one wants to understand, partially, the reason for contemporary "Upheaval" one has to study the following: The Reformation, which led to the Nation-State, which led to Shoa, which brought into existence Vatican II. It seem to me what is the driving force of today's society, the Holy Spirit (?), is reverence for the the sacredness of the individual. This universal craving for dignity is a manifestation of the Kingdom of God in our times. This craving is manifest in the contemporary global social Upheaval, e.g., "Arab Spring." Also, this struggle for respect for the dignity of the individual is taking place, with intensity, in today's election, here in the United States. It is a struggle that can almost be compared to the Civil Rights struggle of the Sixties. It is a struggle for the dignity of the individual, middle class and poor against the Goliaths of wealth and power. As usual "David" has only a sling shot! I think that it is interesting that a person of color is at the center of this struggle, MLK (?). God's Spirit works in surprising and wondrous ways in human history.
8/20/2012 8:55:58 AM
Report abuse

Share with your friends

Add to DeliciousAdd to DiggAdd to NewsvineAdd to RedditAdd to Yahoo MyWebAdd to FarkAdd to TwitterAdd to FacebookAdd to StumbleUponAdd to Google BookmarksAdd to MySpace


Click on the title of any of Fr. Barron's Articles on the left to view the full article.  Please feel free to provide your own comments and feedback. Clicking any of the Tags below will show you a listing of articles and commentaries that relate to the word you click. Click on the RSS link to sign up to be notified of each new item that is published here. Past articles can be found in the archive.

WOF Blog RSS Feed SubscriptionSubscribe to our RSS Feed to receive new articles


2012 A Man For All Seasons A Serious Man abortion Adjustment Bureau Adolph Eichmann advent agnostic Agora Alister angels and deomons apocalypse apologetics Archdiocese of Chicago Ascension atheism Audacity of Hope baptism Barack Obama big bang theory Bin Laden Bob Dylan book Book of Job Brad Caritas in Veritate Carol Marin Catholic Universities celibacy Charles Lwanga Chicago childfree marriages children Christopher Hitchens Civilta Cattolica Coen Brothers commentariat confession conscience contraception devil District 9 dysfunctional Eckhart Tolle Einstein Elijah Emmaus encyclical encyclicals ends and means Evangelization exorcism Father Andrew Greeley Father Barron films financial Fr. Paul Murray Genesis Georgetown golf Hannah Hannah Arendt Hell heresies holocaust interviews Ireland Judge Judy judgement Julia Roberts Kenneth Clark Kierkegaard Laurie Brink Liberal Catholicism Libya lord of the world Lumen Fidei Man of Steel marriage McGrath Mother Teresa movie review muslim nazi nones Notre Dame Nuns Of Gods and Men Palm Sunday PBS Pentecost Peter Snow Pew Forum philosophy Pitt Political Corruption Pope Benedict Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI Pope Francis Pope John Paul II priest pro life prosperity gospel protestantism Purgatory Ralph Grimston Richard McBrien robert hugh benson sacraments Samuel science scientism Sears Tower September 11th sex abuse sexuality Shari’a Law Simon Cowell spiritual St. Irenaeus St. John St. Patrick St. Thomas Aquinas St. Thomas More Superman Ted Kennedy The Hunger Games The Ides of March the shack The Stoning of Soraya M. theologian Time Magazine Timothy Dolan tolerance True Grit Twilight vampires Vatican Willis Tower Woody Allen World War Z World Youth Day YouTube


WORD ON FIRE CATHOLIC MINISTRIES | 5215 Old Orchard Road Suite 410 | Skokie, IL 60077
Add to DeliciousAdd to DiggAdd to NewsvineAdd to RedditAdd to Yahoo MyWebAdd to FarkAdd to TwitterAdd to FacebookAdd to StumbleUponAdd to Google BookmarksAdd to MySpace
Copyright © 2010